Ageology

Under-Eye Pigmentation: Why the Eye Area Looks Dark and How It Can Be Treated

Under-Eye Pigmentation: Why the Eye Area Looks Dark and How It Can Be Treated

Medically reviewed by Dr Sukhsagar Ratol, MBBS, MDPunjab Medical Council Reg. No. 32252Last updated

Darkness under the eyes can look brown in one mirror, grey in another and much deeper in a photograph.

That makes it tempting to label every dark circle as pigmentation. But pigmentation is only one possible contributor. If melanin is part of what you see, the aim is to reduce pigment without irritating the skin enough to create more.

Under-Eye Pigmentation vs Other Dark Circles

Under-eye pigmentation refers to increased or more visible melanin in the skin around the eyes.

That is different from a tear-trough hollow creating shadow. It is also different from thin skin allowing vessels or muscle beneath the surface to influence the colour.

More than one feature can be present together, which is why colour alone is not enough to diagnose the cause.

What you noticeWhat may be contributingHelpful clue
Brown or grey-brown colourMelanin within the skinOften remains visible across lighting
Blue, red or purple toneThin skin and visible underlying colourColour may look more vascular than brown
Darkness that changes with angleTear-trough or structural shadowOften deepens in overhead light
Fullness above a darker bandPuffiness or an under-eye bagContour creates shadow rather than pigment

One useful clue is consistency. Pigment tends to remain visible even when the lighting changes, while a structural shadow may become much deeper or softer depending on the angle.

That is only a clue, not a diagnosis. Mixed dark circles are common.

Dermatologist’s Perspective: Treat the Irritation Before Chasing the Pigment
Dr Sukhsagar Ratol, MBBS, MD • Founder & Director, Ageology Skin Clinic
If rubbing, eczema or dermatitis is still irritating the eye area, adding stronger brightening products can work against you. Ongoing inflammation can keep triggering more pigment.
Calming the trigger and protecting the skin barrier may need to come first. Otherwise, you may keep treating the colour while the reason it is returning is still active.

Common Causes of Under-Eye Pigmentation

If melanin is involved, the next step is to find out why it has become more visible.

Natural or Inherited Pigmentation

Some people naturally have more visible pigmentation around the eyelids and under-eye area. Family tendency and skin phototype can influence how noticeable it is.

This may be present from a younger age and does not mean the skin is unhealthy.

Post-Inflammatory Pigmentation

The eyelid area can become inflamed from eczema, dermatitis, allergy or repeated rubbing.

After inflammation settles, extra pigment can sometimes remain. This is post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.

The cycle can continue if the trigger is still present. Itching leads to rubbing, rubbing adds irritation, and this can leave more visible pigment behind.

Sun and Light Exposure

Ultraviolet and visible light can influence melanin production and can make hyperpigmentation harder to control. Photoprotection is therefore part of managing hyperpigmentation, even when the darker area is close to the eyes.

The aim is not to avoid normal daylight. It is to reduce repeated exposure that can keep pigment pathways active.

CAUTION WITH STRONG ACTIVES AROUND THE EYES

The skin around the eyes is not a good place to keep adding stronger acids, scrubs or brightening products simply because pigment is stubborn.

Over-treatment can leave the eye area dry or inflamed. In skin that is prone to post-inflammatory pigmentation, that irritation can leave more colour behind.

A better approach is to control the trigger, protect the skin barrier and introduce pigment treatment at a strength the periocular skin can actually tolerate.

Skincare for Under-Eye Pigmentation

Skincare is often the first treatment layer when pigment is superficial and the skin barrier is stable.

A plan may include:

  • Broad-spectrum sun protection, applied carefully around the eye area
  • A gentle moisturiser when dryness or barrier irritation is present
  • Selected pigment-modulating ingredients chosen for the person’s skin type and tolerance
  • Treatment of eczema, dermatitis or allergy when those are driving repeated inflammation
  • Avoiding rubbing, harsh exfoliation and unplanned combinations of strong actives
Topical treatment for hyperpigmentation is not instant. Improvement is usually gradual, and stopping the source of irritation can be just as important as adding a brightening ingredient. Not every facial pigment product is appropriate close to the eyelids. The formulation, concentration and placement matter.

Brown under-eye darkness can come from pigment, but pigment is not the only reason the area looks dark.

In-Clinic Treatment Options

If skincare alone is not enough, selected procedures may be considered after the type of pigmentation has been assessed.

Two in-clinic options sometimes considered are superficial chemical peels and pigment-targeting lasers. Both require careful selection because the under-eye area is thin and easily irritated.

Superficial Chemical Peels

Chemical peels use controlled exfoliation to target superficial pigment.

A 2020 comparative study of 90 Indian patients with constitutional periorbital pigmentation found improvement with 20% glycolic acid, 15% lactic acid and 12% ferulic acid peels over 12 weeks. Irritation differed between the groups and was least frequent with ferulic acid (Dayal, Sangal and Sahu, 2020).

That matters around the eyes because a peel that is effective but too irritating may be a poor trade-off for someone prone to post-inflammatory pigmentation. Peel strength, contact time and distance from the eyelid margin need professional judgement.

Q-Switched Laser Treatment

Pigment-targeting lasers can be useful for selected cases of melanin-related under-eye pigmentation.

Q-switched devices send short pulses of light into melanin. They only make sense when melanin is genuinely part of the problem. Settings also need to suit the person’s skin tone.

Evidence for periorbital pigmentation is limited and device-specific, so laser treatment should be selected cautiously rather than used for every dark-looking under-eye (Alavi et al., 2022; Beer et al., 2026).

A pigment-targeting laser will not fix a hollow or a bag. It will not treat visible vessels in the same way either. Even when melanin is the right target, skin tone affects how cautiously the procedure should be planned.

SKIN TONE AND PIGMENT TREATMENT

In deeper skin tones, irritation itself can trigger post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. Around the eyes, this makes conservative treatment selection especially important because the skin is thin and easily irritated.

Current Indian and global consensus recommendations support an individualised approach. Photoprotection matters. Skin phototype matters too. More aggressive treatment is not automatically better (Passeron et al., 2026; Sarkar et al., 2026).

For procedures such as peels or lasers, conservative settings and appropriate aftercare matter. The goal is to treat existing pigment without creating another inflammatory trigger.

Before Choosing a Pigment Treatment

If you are not sure whether you are seeing pigment or shadow, do not choose the treatment first. Assessment should separate the two before anything is done.

It may look at:

• Whether pigment is actually visible within the skin

• Whether the colour is brown, grey-brown, red, blue or mixed

• Whether the darkness changes substantially with lighting or angle

• Whether a tear trough or under-eye puffiness is adding shadow

• Whether eczema, allergy, rubbing or previous irritation is present

• Previous skincare, peels, lasers or other under-eye treatments

• Skin tone and risk of post-inflammatory pigmentation

If the main issue turns out to be hollowing or puffiness rather than melanin, a pigment treatment is unlikely to solve the whole concern. The history matters as much as the photograph.

Pigment, visible vessels and shadow can look surprisingly similar under the eyes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I tell if my dark circles are pigmentation?

Pigmentation usually remains visible across different lighting conditions, while a shadow from hollowing may change more noticeably with angle. Colour can only provide clues, so persistent or mixed dark circles are better assessed in context.

Can rubbing the eyes cause pigmentation?

Repeated rubbing can irritate the skin and may contribute to post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, particularly when eczema, dermatitis or allergy is also present.

Can under-eye pigmentation be permanently removed?

No treatment can promise permanent removal. Pigment can return if the skin is irritated again. Inherited tendency and light exposure can also make it more noticeable over time.

Do chemical peels help under-eye pigmentation?

Selected superficial peels may help some forms of pigment-based periorbital darkening. The eye area is sensitive, so peel type and strength need careful selection to avoid excessive irritation.

Can Q-Switch laser treat under-eye pigmentation?

Q-switched lasers may help selected melanin-related pigmentation, but not every dark circle is a pigment problem. Suitability depends on pigment type, skin tone and whether shadow or vascular colour is also contributing.

Why can under-eye pigmentation get darker after treatment?

Irritation and inflammation can trigger post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation in susceptible skin, so stronger treatment can sometimes make the problem harder to control rather than easier.

References

Alavi, S., Goodarzi, A., Nilforoushzadeh, M.A., Mansouri, P., Jafari, M.A., Hejazi, S. and Azizian, Z. (2022) ‘Evaluation of Efficacy and Safety of Low-Fluence Q-Switched 1064-nm Laser in Infra-orbital Hyperpigmentation Based on Biometric Parameters’, Journal of Lasers in Medical Sciences, 13, e16.

Beer, J., Boghosian, T., Sherif, R., Montes, J., Tosti, A., Rohrich, R. and Beer, K. (2026) ‘What’s New With Under Eye Treatment: A Multispecialty Systematic Review of Recent Under Eye Treatments’, Dermatologic Surgery, 52(2), pp. 155–163. 

Dayal, S., Sangal, B. and Sahu, P. (2020) ‘Ferulic acid 12% peel: An innovative peel for constitutional type of periorbital melanosis: Comparing clinical efficacy and safety with 20% glycolic peel and 15% lactic peel’, Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 19(9), pp. 2342–2348. 

Passeron, T., Desai, S.R., Abdallah, M., Al-Niaimi, F., Dlova, N., Grimes, P.E., Ocampo-Candiani, J., Sarkar, R., Xiang, L.F. and Miot, H.A. (2026) ‘Global consensus on the management of melanin hyperpigmentation disorders’, Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology, 40(5), pp. 760–772.

Sarkar, R., Dogra, S., Sinha, S., Vinay, K., Podder, I., Das, A., Swarnkar, B., Chandrashekar, B.S., Mehta, H., Agarwal, M., Kumaran, M.S., Langar, S. and Desai, S.R. (2026) ‘Expert Consensus on the Management of Hyperpigmentation Disorders in India: A Modified Delphi Study by the Pigmentary Disorders Society’, International Journal of Dermatology.

Request Clinical Consultation

Use the form below to request a consultation with Ageology Skin Clinic. The team can assist with appointment scheduling and general treatment enquiries.

By submitting this form, you agree to Ageology using your details to respond to your appointment request. Please review our Privacy Policy for information on how your details are handled.